I'm in favor of the Gmail reply box being on the top, like my previous email program, with the message showing below. Why should I have to click on the 3 dots to really see what I'm replying to, while the email is also still showing above the box if I scroll up ? And if I want to add something to the subject line now I need to click the down arrow and click edit subject; this line should be open to save extra clicking to access it.
Dumb dumb....why not just have a setting so we can just put the box where we want it.